Thursday, January 05, 2012

Recess Bully

So Barack Obama went nuclear on the recess appointments yesterday, naming four people to various positions within government while the Senate was technically not in session:

After making an end run around Senate Republicans to fill the top job at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau on Wednesday, President Barack Obama ran the same play again a few hours later, making three recess appointments to bring the National Labor Relations Board to full strength.

The president used his power to name Sharon Block, Terence Flynn and Richard Griffin to the board, which arbitrates workplace disputes and federal labor issues and has recently drawn considerable fire from Republicans after it sided with an aircraft workers’ union in a dispute with aerospace giant Boeing.

So what should we think about this? I'd go with the following:

  1. It's unfortunate;
  2. It's likely to come back and bite Obama in the future; and
  3. He's the President and he gets to do things like this.
It doesn't make much sense to complain too much about this sort of thing, because every president I can remember has done the same thing. It's how we got a year of John Bolton at the U.N., among other things. If you don't like Obama acting like a king, there are two things to do. First, vote his butt out of office in November. Then, make it clear that presidents who act like kings will get deposed. Historically there hasn't been much of a price to pay for such behavior, which is why we get it. 

Democrats used to complain quite bitterly about Dick Cheney's notions about a unitary executive, but now that Obama is president, they've warmed to the idea considerably. Of course they have. Both parties love to use as much power as they can when they are in a position to wield it. The only power you have, as a citizen, is to stop such things with your ballot. This is an election year, so get to it.

18 comments:

GabbroGuy said...

From the Washington Post: Bill Clinton made 139 recess appointments, 95 to full-time positions. George W. Bush made 171 recess appointments, 99 of them were for full-time gigs. As of Wednesday, President Obama has made 32 recess appointments, all of them to full-time positions, according to the White House.

You say it makes no sense to complain, yet you use terms like "nuclear" and "king" in the post. Did you make the same complaints and insults about Bush, or did you just bitch about the obstructionist Senate with their dumb rules that let anyone block nominees? Your hypocrisy shows quite often, Mark, especially for someone so thoughtful.

GabbroGuy said...

*especially surprising

Mr. D said...

GabbroGuy,

How am I being a hypocrite? I never said he didn't have the right to do it. I just said that if you don't like what Obama is doing, the only recourse you have is to vote him out of office. The same thing obtained with both Clinton and Bush.

If you have a list of terms that I'm allowed to use without offending your sensibilities on the subject, please feel free to share them, by the way.

W.B. Picklesworth said...

I think a distinction is in order. Mr. D is not a journalist who claims to be non-partisan. He is an interested party. Given that, I think he shows remarkable even-handedness in discussing current events.

Anonymous said...

Picklesworth,
I agree, for the most part, with your assessment of Mark's temperment. But I might quibble over its remarkableness;)
And I would point to his use of the term nuclear in the first sentence of his memo as proof.

Surely, if anyone has been going the nuclear route, it is the Republicans in the Senate. They have been practicing full blown Nullification for three years now by subverting the intent of the Constitution; Senate confirmation is really supposed to be by majority vote, but Republicans are abusing the procedural loophole known as the filibuster to turn it into a supermajority.

Both sides have been guilty of the overuse of the filibuster in recent years, but the current GOP minotity in the Senate has taken it to new heights. Going off on Obama's constitutionally allowed recess appointments while failing to mention what they are in response to seems a tad short of Fair and Balanced. And it isn't Mark's perogative to be Fair and Balanced. Nor mine to respond to his arguments flaws.

Regards and Happy New Year to all.
Rich

Mr. D said...

Both sides have been guilty of the overuse of the filibuster in recent years, but the current GOP minotity in the Senate has taken it to new heights. Going off on Obama's constitutionally allowed recess appointments while failing to mention what they are in response to seems a tad short of Fair and Balanced. And it isn't Mark's perogative to be Fair and Balanced. Nor mine to respond to his arguments flaws.

Yep. Which is why my post said:

Both parties love to use as much power as they can when they are in a position to wield it.

I do find the "hypocrisy" charge tiresome, but most people who comment here are, shall we say, nuanced enough to understand why it invariably cuts both ways. ;)

And thank you, WBP -- very nice of you to say what you did.

Gino said...

i think this just shows how the constitution and rule of law are only as valid as the willingness of the one side most eager to to violate them and get away with it.

i'll leave it to history as to what side that is, cause it aint over yet.

Anonymous said...

Mark,
did you just inadvertently shill for Democrats in the Senate?

Rich

Mr. D said...

Rich, I try not to shill for anyone. But there is another factor involved in this situation and I should have explained it better in my post:

The Senate may not be meeting, but it is not currently in recess. It is in what is called a "pro forma session," which means that what Obama did yesterday is actually without precedent and may not be constitutional at all. The senators did not call a formal recess precisely because they were trying to block Obama from making any recess appointments at this time.

Should the Senate do this? Maybe not. Probably not, even. But it is the Senate's prerogative to do what it did. And Obama basically told the entire Senate to screw itself. He may get by with it, but I suspect this will be adjudicated soon.

This is what I meant when I said Obama "went nuclear." It is, per my understanding, not a business as usual recess appointment scenario.

Mr. D said...

Rich,

Further to the last comment this article explains what a pro forma session is and how it was used in 2008 to stop Bush from making recess appointments. Note how pleased the Senate Democrats are to be doing it, too.

CousinDan 54915 said...

When you vote his butt out, you also get to vote out Michelle's butt, which has brought a lot of controversy in Wisconsin lately.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

The first thing you should remember is that this is not a mall nor a department store.
There are one or two different systems of inhalation to make a choice
from when on the lookout for your vaporizer.
But no, it does not give you energy but it does
kill your lungs and provide you with lungs cancer.


Feel free to visit my site volcano vaporizer

Anonymous said...

This does not imply that these kinds of products are free of contaminants however.
Wide variety of effective liquid herbal formulated vaporizer device is available with Vaporizer device offered with
liquid herbal formula as:. Every section of society is getting involved to increase the consciousness about health.


Feel free to surf to my blog - pocket vaporizer

Anonymous said...

As the temperature increases, air can hold more water vapor.

Wow, so many of us today know what a vaporizer is and we all have a handy dandy vaporizer with us.
It might be breakfast for dinner or dessert for lunch.

Have a look at my blog - portable vaporizer

Anonymous said...

We agree that the Iolite Vaporizer looks cute and small,
but is it as powerful as the internet makes us believe.
Remember if you have children or pets they may try to play in,
or drink from, the water bowl. In technical terms, the
oscilloscope is used to describe the shape of the wave made by the
current being examined.

Also visit my website portable Vaporizer

Anonymous said...

Some people are indeed questioning how to prevent acne, and finally doing any suggested
effort to prevent acne, yet end up in suffering from the same acne.

Cut the paper templates and arrange them on top of
the second cake (in the same way they were arranged before you cut them,
so they'll all fit). When we speak about Vaporizers, you will be able to find many devices in the list which are attractive at the same time satisfactory that the user can be out of smoking in no time.

Here is my web page Volcano Vaporizer

Anonymous said...

Ιf you аre goіng for most exсellent contentѕ like I dο, onlу
gο tо sеe this sitе all the time sinсe іt providеs featuгe соntents, thаnkѕ

my site; payday loans